For a NJ driver, is there an easy to get car insurance?

I live in NJ and I've been thru crap with Geico, when I asked Progressive to help me figure out how to lower my bill, their suggestions increased it by about fifty bucks a month. I have four vehicles, three are decent that I want full coverage on. I'm willing to have a high deductible to keep my premium down. I tried esurance, but they want two months up front and I can't afford that. Any suggestions?